Clement Clarke Mini-Wright Digital vs MIR Smart One - Clinical Comparison

Compare Clement Clarke Mini-Wright Digital and MIR Smart One side-by-side with clinical performance scores, FDA status, pricing, and expert recommendations

Select First Device

Select Second Device

Clement Clarke Mini-Wright Digital

88 /100

MIR Smart One

92 /100

+5% higher overall score

Clement Clarke Mini-Wright Digital

Clement Clarke

Score

Price

$220

Evidence

Strong

Buy Now Full Review

Top Rated

MIR Smart One

MIR

Score

Price

$139

Evidence

Strong

Buy Now Full Review

Performance Metrics

Clement Clarke Mini-Wright Digital

MIR Smart One

Performance Metrics

Clement Clarke Mini-Wright Digital

MIR Smart One

Measurement Accuracy

Measures the closeness of the device's readings to a known reference standard.

Meets ATS 1994 standards for precision, with high resolution at lower flow rates to capture subtle changes in pediatric lung function.

Features a factory-calibrated turbine sensor that meets rigorous ATS/ERS accuracy standards for the flow and volume ranges it supports.

+1% better measurement accuracy

Measurement Accuracy

Measures the closeness of the device's readings to a known reference standard.

+1% better

Ease of Use

Evaluates how intuitive the device and its interface are for the average user.

Features straightforward operation with a large memory for review, though the lack of digital data export requires manual entry for long-term clinical records.

Extremely straightforward to use; the automated traffic light system provides instant, easy-to-understand feedback on the patient's respiratory status.

+11% better ease of use

Ease of Use

Evaluates how intuitive the device and its interface are for the average user.

+11% better

Build Quality

Assesses the durability, materials, and physical design of the device.

Uniquely engineered with a totally sealed, waterproof housing that allows for full submersion during sanitation.

Build Quality

Assesses the durability, materials, and physical design of the device.

Value for Money

Compares the device's features and performance against its retail price.

While it lacks smartphone connectivity, its extreme durability and FEV1 tracking offer significant value for long-term clinical or heavy home use.

Offers excellent value as an entry-level smart device, especially since the reusable turbine minimizes the need for ongoing disposable supply purchases.

+10% better value for money

Value for Money

Compares the device's features and performance against its retail price.

+10% better

App Quality

Measures the functionality, stability, and user interface of the companion digital application.

The MIR Smart One app is intuitive, allowing users to easily record symptom scores, view trend graphs, and export professional PDF reports to share with clinicians.

+100% better app quality

App Quality

Measures the functionality, stability, and user interface of the companion digital application.

+100% better

Clinical Efficacy

Clement Clarke Mini-Wright Digital

MIR Smart One

Clinical Efficacy

Clement Clarke Mini-Wright Digital

MIR Smart One

Peak Flow Accuracy

Measures the precision of Peak Expiratory Flow rate readings.

Validated through ATS standard waveform testing, maintaining high fidelity across the full measurement range of 60-880 L/min.

Peak Flow Accuracy

Measures the precision of Peak Expiratory Flow rate readings.

Measurement Repeatability

Assesses the consistency of results across multiple identical maneuvers.

A simulated 2-year use cycle demonstrated no loss in repeatability, ensuring consistent longitudinal tracking of respiratory health.

Measurement Repeatability

Assesses the consistency of results across multiple identical maneuvers.

Effort-Dependent Sensitivity

Evaluates how effectively the device captures the initial burst of a forced breath.

The pressure sensor architecture is highly responsive to the rapid pressure spikes of a forced exhalation maneuver.

Effort-Dependent Sensitivity

Evaluates how effectively the device captures the initial burst of a forced breath.

Asthma Zone Management

Measures the effectiveness of the device in helping users track their asthma action plan zones.

Relies on an included manual paper diary for recording readings; does not feature automated digital zone alerts.

Asthma Zone Management

Measures the effectiveness of the device in helping users track their asthma action plan zones.

FEV1 Measurement Accuracy

Measures the precision of Forced Expiratory Volume in the first second.

Maintains high linearity and accuracy for FEV1, providing reliable data for tracking airway obstruction.

+100% better fev1 measurement accuracy

FEV1 Measurement Accuracy

Measures the precision of Forced Expiratory Volume in the first second.

+100% better

FVC Measurement Accuracy

Measures the precision of Forced Vital Capacity readings.

This specific model does not measure FVC; it is designed exclusively for basic PEF and FEV1 tracking.

FVC Measurement Accuracy

Measures the precision of Forced Vital Capacity readings.

Longitudinal Trend Tracking

Evaluates the device's ability to consistently track respiratory changes over time.

The integrated app excels at recording historical data and mapping it to personalized GLI predicted sets.

+100% better longitudinal trend tracking

Longitudinal Trend Tracking

Evaluates the device's ability to consistently track respiratory changes over time.

+100% better

Clinical Spirometry Correlation

Assesses how closely the home measurements align with formal clinical pulmonary function tests.

High correlation for the parameters it tests (PEF/FEV1), but limited in overall diagnostic scope due to the absence of FVC and complex ratios.

+100% better clinical spirometry correlation

Clinical Spirometry Correlation

Assesses how closely the home measurements align with formal clinical pulmonary function tests.

+100% better

Specifications

Specification	Clement Clarke Mini-Wright Digital	MIR Smart One
Price	$220	$139
FDA Status	FDA 510(k) Cleared	FDA 510(k) Cleared
Clinical Evidence	Strong Clinical Evidence	Strong Clinical Evidence
Clinical Recommendation	Recommended	Recommended
Connectivity	usb	bluetooth

Value for Money

88 score / $220

40.0

value score

92 score / $139

66.2

value score

65% better value

Value score = Performance score ÷ Price × 100

Clement Clarke Mini-Wright Digital

Strengths

✓ Waterproof, sealed design allows for full submersion during cleaning.
✓ Measures both Peak Flow (PEF) and FEV1 parameters.
✓ Large internal memory stores up to 240 measurement sets.
✓ Rugged build quality designed to withstand clinical environments.
✓ Meets or exceeds ATS technical standards for accuracy.

Limitations

× Does not feature Bluetooth or smartphone connectivity.
× Battery is not user-replaceable (designed for unit life).
× Lacks an automated digital interface for asthma zone calculation.

MIR Smart One

Strengths

✓ Factory-calibrated reusable turbine ensures consistent accuracy.
✓ Seamless Bluetooth pairing with the intuitive MIR Smart One app.
✓ Traffic light health indicator provides immediate, actionable feedback.
✓ Allows for easy sharing of PDF reports with healthcare providers.
✓ Calculates results based on personalized GLI predicted sets.

Limitations

× Does not measure Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) or advanced COPD metrics.
× Relies entirely on a smartphone or tablet; no built-in screen.
× Reusable turbine requires diligent cleaning to maintain hygiene and accuracy.

Expert Review Summary

Our clinical assessment and verdict for each device

Clement Clarke Mini-Wright Digital

Recommended

"The Mini-Wright Digital is a robust and highly hygienic monitor that excels in multi-patient or clinical environments thanks to its fully submersible, sealed design."

The Clement Clarke Mini-Wright Digital is a professional-grade electronic Peak Flow Meter (PFM) and FEV1 monitoring device designed for both home and clinical use. Its standout engineering feature is a totally sealed architecture, making the device completely waterproof and capable of being fully submerged in liquid for thorough cleaning and disinfection-a critical advantage for infection control. Unlike many digital monitors that use turbine technology, the Mini-Wright Digital utilizes a microprocessor and pressure sensor to calculate flow and volume. Clinical testing demonstrates strict adherence to American Thoracic Society (ATS) 1994 standardization guidelines. The device includes an internal memory capable of storing 240 sets of readings, doubling the capacity of previous electronic models. While it focuses on being a high-durability standalone tool, it does not offer modern Bluetooth or PC connectivity, instead prioritizing a low-power design where the internal battery is intended to last for the entire two-year design life of the unit without replacement.

Strong Clinical Evidence

Read Full Review

MIR Smart One

Recommended

"An accessible and user-friendly Bluetooth spirometer that excels in tracking basic asthma metrics like PEF and FEV1, though it lacks advanced parameters for complex COPD staging."

The MIR Smart One stands out as a premier over-the-counter (OTC) entry point for decentralized respiratory diagnostics. Our evaluation focused on its ability to provide accurate Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF) and Forced Expiratory Volume in one second (FEV1) measurements in a home environment. Utilizing a reusable, factory-calibrated turbine flowmeter and Bluetooth Low Energy connectivity, the device interfaces seamlessly with the MIR Smart One mobile application. While it does not capture Forced Vital Capacity (FVC) or other complex parameters needed for advanced COPD staging, clinical testing protocols demonstrated high concordance with laboratory spirometry equipment for the parameters it does measure. The inclusion of an automated traffic-light indicator system makes it exceptionally well-suited for patients tracking daily asthma symptoms and identifying early signs of airway narrowing.

Strong Clinical Evidence

Read Full Review

Where to Buy

Verified purchase options and current availability

Clement Clarke Mini-Wright Digital

$220 MSRP

No retailer information available

Manufacturer Site

HSA/FSA: Usually Eligible

MIR Smart One

Top Choice

$139 MSRP

CardiacDirect

$139.00

3-5 business days Free shipping; FSA/HSA eligible.

Shop

MFI Medical

$150.00

3-5 business days Free shipping in contiguous US; 30-day free returns.

Shop

MDMaxx

$150.00

3-5 business days Medicare HCPCS code pending (approved as DME item by CMS).

Shop

Manufacturer Site

HSA/FSA: Usually Eligible

Important Purchase Considerations

• Prices shown are current as of the last update and may vary. Always verify pricing at the retailer's website.
• Some medical devices may require a prescription. Check with your healthcare provider before purchasing.
• Check with your HSA/FSA administrator for potential reimbursement eligibility and documentation requirements.
• Look for authorized retailers to ensure product authenticity and warranty validity.